Analysis of a Split Decision
The week before last, the U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) ruled unconstitutional President Joe Biden’s executive order requiring large businesses (more than 100 employees) to ensure their employees were vaccinated and tested.
“Although Congress has indisputably given Occupational Safety and Health Administration( OSHA) the power to regulate occupational dangers, it has not given that agency the power to regulate public health more broadly. Requiring the vaccination of 84 million Americans, selected simply because they work for employers with more than 100 employees, certainly falls in the latter category,” the majority opinion said. The vote was 6-3 with the three liberal justices – Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan — dissenting.
In the minority opinion, the three wrote: “When we are wise, we know not to displace the judgments of experts, acting within the sphere Congress marked out and under Presidential control, to deal with emergency conditions,” they wrote. “Today, we are not wise. In the face of a still-raging pandemic, this Court tells the agency charged with protecting worker safety that it may not do so in all the workplaces needed. As disease and death continue to mount, this Court tells the agency that it cannot respond in the most effective way possible.”
In a second ruling regarding vaccine mandates, the SCOTUS allowed the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to require health care workers to be vaccinated at facilities that receive federal monies. In that case, the vote was 5-4, with Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh joining the three liberals (who vote as a bloc) to form the majority.
The majority opinion concluded the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS) routinely imposes conditions of participation (COPs) relating to the qualifications and duties of healthcare workers.
They said the vaccine mandate fell into the duties of HHS.
First, the SCOTUS got the OSHA ruling correct. Telling private employers, the conditions of employment (COPs) for their employees is not a function of the federal government. The feds are already overregulating private businesses to death. Establishing guidelines on workplace safety is why OSHA was created in 1970, but requiring employee jabs has never been a function of that agency. Biden’s executive order was over the top — even for the federal government.
Second, the SCOTUS got the HHS ruling wrong.
Holding hospitals hostage by withholding federal monies if workers don’t get vaccinated is nothing short of extortion. Healthcare workers should have the same liberty and choice as the private sector employees in the OSHA case. They should be allowed to make up their own mind about the vaccine in the same way. This ruling will create more pressure on the health care system in the U.S. as hospital operators across the country expect it will create manpower shortages.
Third, the split decision by the SCOTUS on similar cases is puzzling.
Why did Justices Roberts and Kavanaugh vote for liberty for some Americans, but not others? They cited the authority/mission of the federal agency-HHS- as their justification for requiring the jab for healthcare workers. Were the “rights” of Americans working in the healthcare sector considered? It appears not. When the High Court places the duties/mission of a federal bureaucratic agency over the rights of individual Americans, they are violating their commitment to rule based on the Constitution.
America’s republic system of self-government empowers individual citizens. The United States government is given power by the people, not the other way around. The founding document- the Constitution- is the rule book. It states every American has the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. When a citizen’s rights or liberty is taken away- for whatever purpose- it violates the rule book. When the liberty of one is taken away for the overall good of the whole, America ceases to be America.
Note: Steve Fair is Chairman of the Republican Party in the Fourth Congressional District of Oklahoma. Steve’s conservative commentaries appear regularly at the CapitolBeatOK.com news website. Contact him by email at email@example.com. His blog is stevefair.blogspot.com.